Saturday 23 September 2017, 14.30, New Dundas Park
Scottish Junior Cup First Round action between East Super League’s Bonnyrigg Rose and Shettleston of the West Super League First Division.
It was good to get to the football after plans to go to the League Cup Quarter Final between Motherwell and Aberdeen on the Thursday and the Scottish Cup tie between Spartans and Vale of Leithen both didn’t pan out.
A first sight of Rose this season and despite the fantastic season they had in 2016-17, they ended up empty handed. They will be looking to rectify that this season.
Runners-up in the East Super League to the now senior side Kelty Hearts, a semi-final defeat in the Junior Cup to Glenafton, a penalty shoot-out defeat to Tranent in the East of Scotland Cup Final and a run to the fourth round of the Scottish Cup where they went out to a clinical Hibs. The plaudits were plentiful, but the silverware was not as the number of games caught up with them at the end of the season.
Since last season, they have signed goalkeeper Bryan Young from Whitehill Welfare, left back Neil Martynuik and midfielder Lee Currie from Newtongrange Star, Ross Gray from Linlithgow Rose, Mark McConnell from Edinburgh City and right back Dean Brett, who had left Rose to join Montrose, but changed his mind and came back.
Left back Ruaridh Donaldson has signed for Stenhousemuir, Chris Tobin has gone to Craigroyston, Scott Gray has gone to the United States and Ross Archibald has re-retired. Striker Sean Jamieson went to Penicuik Athletic in the week leading up to the game against Shettleston. The biggest loss has been the departure of manager Robbie Horn, who has taken the reins at Berwick Rangers. Coach David White has stepped into the Rose hot seat.
Rose have had six wins and two draws in the league and sat in second place, two points behind leaders Penicuik.
It’s a long time since I’ve seen Shettleston in action. Formed in 1903 they are nicknamed ‘The Town’ and are currently in the West Super League First Division, the second top league in the West Juniors.
They started life playing at Well Park, but were forced to vacate at short notice in 1932 as the land was required for house building. They moved to Frank Field Park and renamed it Greenfield Park, where they still play their home fixtures today, in the East End of Glasgow.
They have won a number of trophies in their history including the Central A League in 1959-1960 and 1976-1977 and the West of Scotland Cup in 1974-1975, 1992-1993 and 1994-1995.
Their solitary appearance in the Junior Cup Final came in 1959 when they lost 2-1 to Irvine Meadow at Hampden Park. They also reached the semi-final in 2001.
They have become a bit of a yo-yo club in recent times and most recently played in the top league in 2014-15, but it was a one season stay. Last season saw them finish in seventh spot.
Some may recognise the name of goalkeeper Gary Whyte. He gained nationwide fame last season for being sent off in a match against Shotts Bon Accord for urinating behind his own goal during the match.
It’s been a tumultuous start to the season for Shettleston. A new management duo of James McKenna and Keith Docherty were sacked 36 days after being appointed and just before the start of the season. The two had made a raft of signings after being left with just 4 players for the season ahead.
Seven players had come on board from Broomhouse Amateurs where Docherty had been manager, and a further nine had also been signed up. Hugh Kelly and Bernie Beacom have now taken on the managerial duties and several of the players brought in over the summer departed after the changes in management.
It had been a tough start and they went into the cup tie rooted to the bottom of the league, with a solitary point from their five games and they also finished bottom of their Central Sectional League Cup Group.
There’s been a few changes at New Dundas Park since we were last there, with some smoothing of ground and new dugouts etc. Although it may have been the undulations of the pitch, it looked as if the edge of the box had been lined by someone at the end of a night out.
There were around 250 in attendance.
Rose looked to make a positive start and in the opening minute McIntosh found Gray on the left, but his ball into the middle was too hard for anyone to get on the end of.
As a gentleman arrived next to us, he was greeted with “Alright Jock, how’s things?” Jock replied “F*cking terrible.” When asked what was wrong, he replied “oh nothing, just living the dream.”
In the sixth minute, Hoskins struck a shot on the Shettleston goal from the left which whistled just past the post.
Brown curled a free kick towards goal in 13 minutes from around 22 yards, but it hit the side netting of the visitor’s goal.
With 17 minutes gone, Martin trotted across to take a Shettleston free kick and sent an attempted cross behind the goal for a bye-kick. This was the second time he had wasted one from a promising position.
Brett crossed into the Shettleston box in 18 minutes and the ball was booted high in the air by a defender. It dropped at the edge of the box to McIntosh, whose half volley was just wide of the post.
McGachie was next to have a go from the edge of Shettleston’s box, but he skyed his shot from 20 yards.
Rose’s Moyes had to go off for treatment in 20 minutes with a bleeding nose but quickly returned to the fray.
In 23 minutes, Hoskins took out Makofo on the right touchline. Martin went across to take the free kick and again sent the ball behind the goal.
Shettleston worked the ball to Kisuka near the edge of the Rose box in 25 minutes, but his shot lacked power and it was comfortable for Young, although Kisuka may have been caught as he struck it.
A long ball forward into the Shettleston box by Young in 28 minutes saw a defender put the ball behind. Currie’s corner was met powerfully by the head of Young and it flew into the top corner to give the hosts the lead.
Young was involved again in 31 minutes when his through ball saw McGachie racing into the box on the right and as Whyte came out he dinked it over him, but could only hit the side netting.
Rose put some good football together in 37 minutes after Currie had intercepted the ball in midfield. It ended with Brown playing the ball to Currie who beat a defender before seeing his shot take a nick as it went narrowly wide.
A minute later Rose came forward again and Gray passed to McIntosh on the right. His cross was taken down expertly by Gray before he volleyed just wide of goal.
After McDowell had been booked for a foul on McGachie, Brown put Rose’s free kick into the box in 41 minutes. It was half cleared but played back in to McGachie who looked to miskick, which took him somewhat fortuitously past the keeper, before he rolled it into the net to make it two-nil.
Scott picked up the game’s first booking in 43 minutes, for taking out Rose’s McIntosh as Bonnyrigg broke.
Two nil to the home side at the interval.
With three minutes of the second half gone Currie chipped the ball into the Shettleston box for Brett, but he couldn’t keep his header down.
A Brett cross from the right in 49 minutes picked out the head of McGachie in the heart of the Shettleston box and his clever header completely wrong-footed Whyte, but shaved the post as it went wide.
McGachie was brought down just outside the “D” on the edge of the Shettleston box in 60 minutes and it was three Rose defenders who discussed who would take it. Brett eventually won the argument and his effort took a deflection off the wall and spun into the net past a helpless Whyte to make it three.
Rose showed no sign of being happy to rest on their lead and when McGachie laid the ball back to Brown in 62 minutes, his first time cross picked out Brett at the back post, but he headed over.
Shettleston’s McIntosh needed treatment in 65 minutes after a challenge by Hoskins. He limped back on soon after. He only lasted another five minutes though.
Kisuka won the ball for Shettleston in 70 minutes and Luczi took it forward, but his shot was too high.
In 74 minutes, Brett cut the ball back to Turner from the Shettleston by-line, but Whyte blocked his shot.
Martin was yellow carded in 75 minutes for bringing down a Rose player on the side of the box after being nutmegged. Brown played the free kick back to Currie on the edge of the box and he hit a very well controlled shot low into the corner for Rose’s fourth.
A Rose corner in 80 minutes by Currie was met well by the head of McConnell, but Whyte pushed the ball away from goal.
McEwan picked up a loose ball in 82 minutes and had a go at the Rose goal, but there wasn’t sufficient power in his shot to trouble Young.
With 6 minutes to go Brett’s cross into the Shettleston area eluded everyone in the middle and came to Martynuik at the far post. He fired the ball back into the mix and McConnell showed good reactions to nod the ball into the net to make it 5-0.
Currie played a one-two with McGachie inside the Shettleston box in 87 minutes, but off balance, he was unable to get a good strike on the ball and Whyte gathered.
In injury time Young was booked for bringing down Kisuka as Shettleston looked to break.
An easy win for Bonnyrigg who never really looked to be at the top of their game but were very comfortable throughout. A tough afternoon for Shettleston but they never gave up and kudos goes to them for continuing to try to play football as the match progressed.
Moyes and Currie were both excellent for Rose and Brown also had a very good game, although the whole defence looked very solid. Shettleston won’t be up against that level of defender every week, but Kisuka, McIntosh and Makofo all showed good touches which suggests they will cause problems in the league this season.
Rather than the Shettleston keeper, it was the crowd that were relieved this time. Relieved that he managed to hold on until after the game to go to the toilet.
Full Time: Bonnyrigg Rose 5 Shettleston Juniors 0
Admission: £6
Bonnyrigg Rose: 1 Bryan Young, 2 Dean Brett, 5 Ewan Moyes, 4 Kerr Young, 6 Dean Hoskins, 3 Jonny Brown (Martynuik 78), 7 Scott Gray (Turner 66), 11 Lee Currie, 10 Alan Horne, 9 Wayne McIntosh (McConnell 57), 11 Kieran McGachie. Subs: 12 Neil Martynuik, 14 Lewis Turner, 15 Adam Nelson, 16 Mark McConnell, 25 Michael Andrews.
Shettleston Juniors: 1 Gary Whyte, 2 Lee Martin, 3 Robert Crumlish, 4 Michael McDowell, 5 Calum Nolan, 6 Ryan Scott, 7 Mate Luczi, 8 Cristiano Kisuka, 9 Rikki McIntosh (McEwan 75), 10 Steffa Graham (Treacy 66), 11 Makofo (Kelly 75). Subs: 12 Greg McEwan, 14 Stuart Kelly, 15 Kyle Robertson, 16 Cathal Tracey, 17 Gareth Watson.
Referee: Alastair Grieve
Programme: None.